Fundamentals of Mental Health

Fundamentals of Mental Health

Comparing the effectiveness of cognitive therapy based on mindfulness with Jacobsen's relaxation technique on test anxiety in female elementary students

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
Hassan Bagherinia 1
Fatemeh Bahrami 2
1 Assistant professor, Department of Educational Science, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran.
2 Assistant professor of educational psychology, Department of Educational Science, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran.
10.22038/jfmh.2023.22754
Abstract
Introduction: The research aims to determine the effectiveness of teaching techniques based on mindfulness and relaxation on students' test anxiety.
 
Materials and Methods: The statistical population of this descriptive-comparative study consisted of female students in the second year of the elementary Sama school in Sabzevar city-Iran (84 students). Thirty-six students with high score of test anxiety were selected and they were randomly divided into three groups (mindfulness training, muscle relaxation, and the control group). Two experimental groups received intervention during eight sessions. All participants simultaneously fulfilled test anxiety questionnaire one month after the intervention. Data analyzed through the t-test of independent groups, one-way analysis of variance, Tukey's test, and SPSS software.
 
Results: The findings showed that mindfulness training and Jacobsen's relaxation technique reduced test anxiety significantly in female students, but mindfulness training has greater effect size than relaxation technique (0.67 vs 0.58).
 
Conclusion: Based on the results, it seems that cognitive therapy based on mindfulness can reduce test anxiety in elementary students more than Jacobsen's relaxation technique.
Keywords
Mindfulness
Relaxation
Test anxiety
  1. Sheykholeslami A, Gamari Kivi K, Ashrafi Vorjoi S. [The effect of knowledge-based learning method on self-control of girl students]. Quarterly journal of research in educational systems 2016; 9: 87-104. (Persian)
  2. Yazdani Baghmaleki A, Mehri M, Habib Elahi Najafabadi S. [Evaluation of the effectiveness of acceptance and commitment-based therapy on academic performance and exam anxiety of female high school students]. Journal of new approaches in educational sciences 2022; 4(2): 41-48. (Persian)
  3. Moshtaghiyan M. [Comparison of students' academic performance: boarding schools with day schools]. Qaemshahr: Yasna Scientific Publications; 2015. (Persian)
  4. Pourtaleb N, Mirnasab M. [The relationship between hopelessness and academic self-concept with test anxiety among sixth grade primary students.] Journal of instruction and evaluation 2016; 11: 13-27. (Persian)
  5. Shifteh A, Bahremandjou S. [Prediction of academic performance and anxiety in adolescents' exams based on parenting styles and parental intimacy]. The journal of new advances in behavioral sciences 2017; 2(3): 14-30. (Persian)
  6. Emadifar F, Gousof Y. [Effectiveness of attention training on attention control, focused attention and dispersed attention in girl students with test anxiety]. Quarterly journal of child mental health 2017; 4: 67-77. (Persian)
  7. Heiser P, Simidian G, Albert D, Garruto J, Catucci D, Faustino P, et al. Anxious for success: High anxiety in New York's schools. New York: School Boards Association; 2015: 1-8.
  8. Krispenz A, Gort C, Schulte L, Dickhäuser O. How to reduce test anxiety and academic procrastination through inquiry of cognitive appraisals: A pilot study investigating the role of academic self-efficacy. Front Psychol 2019; 10: 1917.
  9. Brady ST, Hard BM, Gross JJ. Reappraising test anxiety increases academic performance of first-year college students. J Educ Psychol 2018; 110(3): 395-406.
  10. Varasteniya M, Ojinejad A. [Predicting academic achievement motivation through academic adjustment, burnout, and test anxiety]. Educational and scholastic studies 2022; 11(1): 505-31. (Persian)
  11. Fathi A, Barmehziar S, Mohebi S. [Survey test anxiety in pre-university students in Qom and its related factors in 2016]. Education strategies in medical sciences 2017; 10(4): 270-76. (Persian)
  12. Mardon N, Richard H, Martindale A. The effect of mindfulness training on attention and performance in national-level swimmers: An exploratory investigation. Sport Psychol 2016; 30(2): 131-40.
  13. Saadipour E, Soltanizadeh H, Ebrahimghavam S. [The effectiveness of mindfulness based cognitive therapy on self-control and academic performance of students with high/low level of test anxiety]. Quarterly journal of child mental health 2020; 7(2): 183-94. (Persian)
  14. Chapari I, Yousefy B, Zardoshtian Sh. [The effect of coaching behaviors on self-efficacy and team performance in Iranian women Football ProLeague]. Sport management journal 2020; 12(1): 19-33. (Persian)
  15. Roodsarabi M, Abedi B, Farsi F. [The effect of relaxation and mindfulness on female adolescent sports anxiety]. Journal of motor and behavioral sciences 2020; 3: 237-45. (Persian)
  16. Bagherinia H, Yazdimoghadam A. The effectiveness of mindfulness-based therapy on goal orientation in adolescent girls. The Third International Conference of Psychology, Educational Sciences and Lifestyle; 2016. Mashhad, Torbat Heydariyeh University.
  17. Ramezani G, Deljoo J. [The effectiveness of mindfulness-based techniques and self-regulated learning training on test anxiety among students]. Journal of research in teaching 2017; 4(3): 63-78. (Persian)
  18. Rasam A, Gaffsri O, Abolghasemi A, Beyrami M. [Comparison of the effectiveness of optimism training, emotion regulation and mindfulness training in reducing academic burnout in students with test anxiety]. Journal of consulting excellence and psychotherapy 2020; 9: 61-73. (Persian)
  19. Golmohammadi B, Kashani A, Khosravi Jafari A. [The effect of a relaxation program on the performance of semi-skilled futsal players]. Journal of developmental and motor learning 2018; 10(3): 385-411. (Persian)
  20. Motaghi M, Ebrahimzadeh M. [Evaluation of The difference between two non-drug techniques of Benson muscle relaxation and mental imagery on the anxiety of hemodialysis patients in Mahshahr city in 2017: Randomized controlled trial]. Nurse midwifery journal 2019; 16: 881-90. (Persian)
  21. Hejazi E, Sarmad Z, Barazaganharandi A. [Research methods in behavioral sciences]. 11th Tehran: Agah; 2005. (Persian)
  22. Kazemian Moghadam K, Mehrabizadeh M. [Test anxiety and ways to deal with it]. Tehran: Arad; 2010. (Persian)
  23. Abolghasemi A, Golpoor R, Narimani M, Gomari H. [Investigating the relationship between disruptive meta-cognitive beliefs and academic success of students with test anxiety]. Educational and psychological studies 2009; 10(3): 5-20. (Persian)
  24. EL-Zahhar N. Cultural and sexual differences in test anxiety, trait anxiety and arousability. J Cross Cult Psychol 1991; 22(2): 228-49.
  25. Anton WD, Lillridge EM. Case studies of test anxious students. In: Spielberger CD, Vagg RR. (editors). Test anxiety: theory, assessment, and treatment. Washington, DC: Hemisphere/Hastead; 1991.
  26. Bandalos DL, Yates K. Effects of math self- concept, perceived self-efficacy, and attribution for failure and success on test anxiety. J Educ Psychol 1995; 87(4): 611-23.
  27. Register AC, Beckham DJ, May JG, Gustafon DJ. Stress inoculation bibliotherapy in the treatment of test anxiety. J Couns Psychol 1991; 38(2): 115-16.
  28. SegaL ZV, William JMG, Teasdale JD. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy for depression: New approach to preventing relapse. New York: Gilford; 2002.
  29. Jacobson E. Progressive relaxation: A physiological and clinical investigation of muscle state and their significance in psychology and medical practice. Chicago: University of Chicago; 1938.
  30. Alahyari V, Sarabi P, Sayyah S. [The effectiveness of Silva-style psychomotor relaxation on cognitive functions in people with generalized anxiety disorder]. Rooyesh-e-Ravanshenasi 2021; 9: 45-54. (Persian)
  31. Bohlmeijer E, Prenger R, Taal E, Cuijpers P. The effect of mindfulness-based stress reduction therapy on mental health of adults with a chronic medical disease: A meta-analysis. J Psychosom Res 2010; 68: 539-44.
  32. Esmaili A, Gholamrezaee S, Gholamrezaee S. [The aim of this study was to compare the effect of cognitive therapy based on mindfulness, relaxation and medication in reducing test anxiety of gifted female students]. Journal of educational psychology studies 2021; 18: 36-62. (Persian)
  33. Manavipour D, Darabi M, Seyf A. [The effect of mindfulness training on problem solving styles and test anxiety in students]. Social cognition 2018; 7(1): 39-50. (Persian)
  34. Khorrami F, Saif A, Kiamanesh A, Dortaj F. [The effectiveness of mindfulness training in test anxiety and attitudes towards school in 11th grade students]. Quarterly of educational psychology 2019; 14: 25-54. (Persian)
  35. Ghamari M, Hosseini G. [The effectiveness of mindfulness-based stress reduction training program on female students, test anxiety]. Scientific research quarterly of woman and culture 2017; 9: 33-43. (Persian)
  36. Yazdi SM, MehriNezhad A, Nazari F. [Effectiveness of mindfulness training on exam anxiety of female high school students]. Journal of new developments in psychology, educational sciences and education 2021; 4: 172-84. (Persian)
  37. Niknasab F, Zareli M, Fakorean A, Sharbatzadeh R. [Comparison of the effectiveness of mindfulness and mental imagery training on cortisol levels, anxiety and self-confidence in officer students]. Journal of developmental and motor learning 2021; 13(2): 149-62. (Persian)
  38. Roodsarabi M, Abdoli B, Farsi A. [The effect of relaxation and mindfulness on female adolescents sport anxiety]. Journal of motor and behavioral sciences 2020; 3: 237-45. (Persian)
  39. Karami J, Makari Z, Shalani B. [The effectiveness of relaxation training on depression, anxiety, and stress in infertile women]. Journal of Rooyesh-e-Ravanshenasi 2018; 6(4): 242-56. (Persian)
  40. Khabiri M, Moghadam Zadeh A, Mehrsafar AM, Abrisham-kar H. [Comparison of the effectiveness of progressive muscle relaxation with imagery-based relaxation on cortisol levels, competitive anxiety and self-confidence in elite athletes]. Journal of research in psychological health 2017; 11(1): 62-73. (Persian)
Fundamentals of Mental Health
Volume 25, Issue 3
May and June 2023
Pages 189-195